Ohio Insurance Claims Contacts

Need to call in an insurance claim?  Here are the links and phone numbers:

Grange:  1-800-445-3030

Progressive:  1-800-776-4737

Travelers:  1-800-252-4633

Hanover:  1-800-628-0250

United Fire Group (UFG):  1-800-343-9131

National Indemnity:  1-800-356-5750

Liberty Mutual:  1-800-225-2467

Safeco:  1-800-332-3226

Utica:  1-800-216-1420

Trexis:  1-877-384-7466

Encompass:  1-800-588-7400

EMC Insurance:  1-888-362-2255

MetLife:  1-800-854-6011

American Modern:  1-800-375-2075

Nationwide:  1-800-421-3535

Foremost:  1-800-527-3907

American Strategic Insurance (ASI):  1-866-274-5677

Ohio Fair Plan:  614-839-1468

National General 1-800-468-3466